Interviewed by the New York Times’s sports journalism department The Athletic yesterday, Antoine Duval, head of the Asser Institute’s International Sports Law Centre, said: “If the court follows her opinion, any CAS award…will be challengeable before any national court in the EU, on the basis of EU law.”
Duval, whose work was quoted multiple times in Ćapeta’s opinion, emphasised that while such challenges would be costly and time-consuming - and thus only a few athletes and sports clubs would be able to entertain them – the solution advocated by the AG would in any case “facilitate challenges, which ultimately will land at the CJEU.” This, he added, would “further reinforce (the CJEU’s) position as the court of last resort to review transnational sports governance,” signaling a significant shift in the institutional landscape of transnational sports law. The CJEU’s final ruling is expected in the coming months.
The developments in sports arbitration stem from a dispute between Belgian football club RFC Seraing and FIFA over third-party ownership of players. While Seraing’s appeals to both CAS and the Swiss Federal Supreme Court were unsuccessful, the case eventually reached the CJEU via the Belgium courts. The Seraing case comes shortly after another recent ruling of the CJEU in the ISU case, which was initiated by Asser Institute researchers (Ben Van Rompuy (now at Leiden University) and Antoine Duval), had already curtailed the bindingness of CAS arbitration clauses.
Read the full opinion.
About Antoine Duval
Dr Antoine Duval coordinates the research strand on advancing public interests in international and European law. He is a Senior Researcher at the Asser Instituut since February 2014 and defended his PhD at the European University Institute in Florence in September 2015. His thesis dealt with the legal interaction between the Lex Sportiva (the private regulations governing international sports) and EU Law. He is the founder and editor-in-chief of the ASSER International Sports Law Blog, founder and editor of the Yearbook of International Sports Arbitration, and a member of the editorial board of the International Sports Law Journal and International Sports Law book Series of Asser Press. His research focuses on the role of private actors in transnational law, using the lex sportiva as his main case study.
